Home | Reading I | Oral and Written Language | Learning in the Classroom | Math | Social Studies | Reading II | Microcomputers | Science | Children's Literature | Special Needs Populations | Linguistically Diverse Students | Student Teaching/Seminar | Course Electives/Workshops | Leave a Comment

LLSS 443 Children's Literature (Fall '08)

UNM Digital Portfolio

Tibbetts Practicum Reflection
 
9/22/08
We had our first visit at Tibetts today.  I really liked the instructor. She seemed to really enjoy her students and had a good relationship with them. 
We had the chance to share our "I Am From" poems with the students.  I wish more of them had a chance to share theirs.  They were pretty shy at that first meeting.  I'm hoping that changes as we get to know them better!
I'm definitely excited about working with these kids.  Junior high was such a hard time for me.  I got a chance to work with junior highers over the last few years and they have some of the most wonderful assets.  They have a whole lot of personality and havent quite learned the best outlet for it so they are constantly experimenting and open to new ideas.
 
9/29/08
This was a bit of a frustrating day...but it wasn't bad necessarily....ok maybe it was.  One person in our group kind of insisted on giving the kids a history lesson...which they were not at all responsive to.  It was really interesting information, but they were pretty lost the whole time.  Another person in the group and I were trying to get into the conversation to include the kids more, but it was almost like trying to swim upstream.  We're definitely going to have to talk on strategies.  I hate the idea that the kids are already bored to death with this book. :(
 
10/6/08
Today was much better.  We decided to bring snacks for the group which was much appreciated by them.  They seemed a little more relaxed with us.  We still had the one person pushing for a history lesson, but after talking to them afterwards, realized that thats what they thought they were supposed to be doing...giving them a huge amount of background knowledge on the subject so that they would appreciate the story.  The other three of us were under the impression that this was the students time.  We help start up conversations and they lead it from there.  We also believe that they will get the most out of the book if they can appreciate the characters and the emotion in the book and then let that be the reason they learn more about WWII. 
This week we're going to get the kids journals so that the last 5-10 minutes of the meeting time can be used for reflection.  We're also going to give them post-it notes so that they can write any questions/comments that they have during the reading so that will be the start of our group time.
 
10/13/08
Today we had a tiny group!  We only had four boys.  It was funny though because there was more interaction and the boys were more vocal than they had been up to this point.  They said that they preferred the group to be all boys because they felt intimidated and didnt like to talk with the girls around.  How cute!  We didnt even read the text with the group as much because we had enough conversation to fill the time.  We also started journaling today.  We took the last 10 minutes or so and journaled what we felt about the text that we discussed.  We then read our entries.  This week we asked the kids to draw a sketch of a particular part of the book that impacted them.
 
10/20/08
Well heck.  I feel horrible saying this but I feel like our group took a step back today.  We had a nearly full group and they really didnt want to discuss the book at all.  Any time that we would ask a question to get some type of dialogue going, they would look at us like we were out of our minds.  Even after they wrote in our journals, the boys wouldnt share what they had written.  We discussed this after the group and decided that it might be best if we separate boys and girls in future groups. *crosses fingers*
 
10/27/08
Today we decided to do things a little bit differently.  The kids arent really responding to the idea of being open and reflective about the readings.  We decided that it would be best if we read the chapter with them (since they have a really hard time reading and comprehending the text) and then we took time to journal at the end.  We are also assigning drawings.  They need to illustrate one part of the book or chapter that really impacts them.  They then share the pictures.  They're really liking that a lot.
 
11/3/08
Weeeeelllllllll......heck.  Yes I've said it before, but for different reasons.  Before I was just stumped as to how to make this lit. circle work.  Today its because I feel like our leadership team is imploding at the expense of the group.  One person in our group insists that we only need to read to the kids and then tell them facts that we think are interesting.  The rest of us think that it needs to be a discussion group.  It felt a little akward since there was obviously tension. 
We did end with a really great activity (THANKS VAL).  Each of them took a phrase from the chapter that we read together (Round robin :(  ) and we made a poem out of those quotes.  It ended up so neat!  And I really think they enjoyed it as well.  I would definitely like to try that again.  We're also going to try and give them the roles for lit circles to do for next week.  They will read the assigned reading, and then do research for their part.  We're hoping that this will show them that it really does take each of their individual voices to make a really great conversation.  After this, if we have time we're going to have each of them think of a question or statement, and have each of the others respond to it.  I think at this age, if they haven't learned it already, it is critical for them to know that each person's voice is important and valid and worth paying attention to! 
 
11/10/08
Wow.  Today was absolutely amazing.  I'm not sure that I attribute it completely to our change in group leadership...but I will admit that the students definitely felt like that could speak more openly (and candidly!!!) to us and more importantly, to each other!
We began with the literacy "jobs" to kind of open them up about the reading, not only that week, but so far.  They came up with insights using life to book connections that I honestly wouldn't have even though up.  It was incredibly in depth even though many of the times it had a funny connotation.  Afterwards we brought out the keyring of questions and they really enjoyed that as well.  It was the first time that we had to end our conversation because we ran out of time.  It was amazing!  I can't wait to get into this more!
 
11/17/08
I was absent today due to an unexpected emergency.
 
11/24/08
Today was a little hectic at the beginning.  It is right before Thanksgiving break and the kids were a little more wild than usual and Leah had definitely had it.  When we got our group, most of them really had no interest in talking about the book and so Valerie gave them the 'ol "Well I guess we can sit here and stare at each other" speech.  It killed me!  hahaha  Eventually someone brought up Hitler and the kids instantly became engaged in talking about his life and how he related to the book.  It ended really well at least!
 
12/1/08
I cannot believe it is the last day of working at Tibbetts.  It was kind of a goofy and fun day.  Our kids were wired for sound and so absolutely halarious to converse with (it may have also been the sugar and popcorn we all brought :)).  We began by talking about the last of the book.  We had asked the kids if they wanted to read the last chapter together and they said no.  This spurred Valerie to ask them what they thought of our chance in lit circle style - wondering if they liked it better when we were reading everyday or now when we're talking, and they said that even though it got ackward when we didnt talk sometimes, they much preferred the lit circle after we stopped the reading every week!  It was amazing to hear that.  We then each got a piece of paper and wrote something about the book or the lit circle as a whole and after a few minutes, passed it to the next person so they could comment on what the person before them said.  After a few passes I noticed that they were just saying things like "It was ok" and "yeah I agree with what he/she said" and so I put a stop to that really fast!  haha  It ended up being a really great time together and I really don't think that it could have ended better!

Reflection
 

Communication:  I think I have never learned…better stated…forced to learn more about communication in my life than I have this semester in my classes, specifically this one.  It is so vital to having a pleasant classroom experience to have an open line with not only the instructor but with classmates.  With classmates:  it is estimated that a person retains only 10% of what they hear while in any given class.  Chances are, you’ve missed something.  Keeping that communication alive with other students helps lessen the chances that you have forgotten an important piece of information.  With the instructor:  Holy moley.  In the past I have been intimidated to be upfront with my instructor, but Frances, I have really learned to value that with you.  No other teacher ever notices (or at least they don’t tell me that they notice) when my mood shifts or tells me when they are trying to read each of our expressions.  This has caused a few “mishaps” in our relationship, but I feel that I respect you and value your opinion so much more for the ability we have to tell each other exactly what we think and yet joke around and talk about books and movies and the passion and intensity of all that is education the next.  So yeah, in a nutshell…communication is good. J  Another thing that pressed hugely on me with the Children’s Lit course is the communication with the students.  We had a very interesting and sometimes challenging group at Tibbetts.  That is, until we got to know them better and changed the way that we approached our lit circle as a whole.  It was interesting trying to find ways to communicate effectively with a group of very shy middle schoolers!

Research:  Literature circles.  What are they and how are they supposed to be run?  This came up quite frequently at the beginning of our time with our Tibbetts students.  One of the people in my group had a very different idea than the rest of us on how to conduct a lit circle, and so my group had to make sure that we were on top of the latest research into lit groups in order to back our point on the subject.  It was also interesting how the book Night really was like doing research into WWII for our students.  They really hadn’t studied the subject before, so it was neat helping them learn more about what happened during the time of the book.

Technology:  I’m becoming less fond of and more dependant on technology as time goes on.  Part of me wants to completely throw it out the window – wants to go back to when life revolved around enhancing life in its most basic forms – carving wood – writing on paper - using pencils – the feel of books – the excitement of toys and manipulatives – the smell of the outdoors.  Alas, life is moving in another direction and I need to learn to use technology to the best of it’s abilities, and keep a firm balance on real life (not excluding the fact that technology is some kids’ “real life”.)

Collaboration:  Wooooooowwwwwww……you know full well this semester with my lit circle group has really challenged a few of our ways of collaborating effectively with group members.  No matter what, we have to keep in mind that those that we are working with are competent individuals and we need to learn a way to compromise without losing our integrity as instructors – which some of us did, and some of us didn’t.  I just need to remember that sometimes working with certain people is like fireworks and ends up being a beautiful thing….and working with others is like using Black Cats….they are illegal for a reason!

Five Dimensions of Learning

Confidence and Independence:  Kids have no confidence in themselves.  I know that this is a bold and harsh statement, but I’ve notices with working in my classes this semester at Apache, Animas, and Tibbets in such a major and sad way.  Kids are not believing that their work is ever good enough, or they set themselves up with low expectations so that their efforts are not slammed down and it absolutely breaks my heart.  All of these five dimensions of learning flow together, but they begin somewhere – they begin at home on one level and at school on another…and I have honestly seen kindergarten teachers criticizing their students with words and actions that resemble a football coaches.  We are not football coaches.  We are moms and dads and firefighters and nurses and motivational speakers and comedians and…well you get the point.  We are here to build them up.  Not tear them down.  And when we use our abilities to build children up, they become confident and independent and they really can reach the utmost of their abilities.  Our Tibbetts students were prime examples.  In Junior High kids are so self-conscious and we really need to work twice as hard at that level to make sure that kids know that they are competent and smart and that they should not be afraid of themselves,  their classmates, or school!

Knowledge Content:  I’m going to turn this into a statement because it really is something that it hitting me hard.  Knowledge content should not overshadow our instincts as teachers to teach our kids what they need to know…not for the test…but for life.  Yes it is important to know book knowledge – everyone knows that you need that in order to get a good job and be successful (in the mental sense – we are more mentally healthy when we are constantly learning than just stagnant), but we need to realize that our kids come first.  Not our textbooks.  The more life experiences we can give our kids, the more they will be curious to know what it’s about and how it works.  It was a bit hard with Tibbetts in that reading Night was foreign to them since they really didn’t know anything about WWII going into the circle.  One person in our group decided that they needed to give them a history lesson every week, and the others of us believed that if we could connect them with the emotion and the events of the book with their real life, then in the end, they would learn more about the subject…which ended up happening.  They told us at the end of the time with them that they really didn’t like hearing history lessons, but when they could connect different parts of the book to what was happening in their lives, they were able to learn more about the subject.

Skills and Strategies:  There are so many skills and strategies I don’t even know where to begin.  You know first hand the trouble we were going through and the heads that were butting during the practicum time at Tibbetts.  That was a prime example of different skills and strategies and trying to get the kids to learn in different ways.  In the end, it went well because the kids began to trust us more as instructors, but we were constantly trying new and different ways of connecting to our students so that they could take the most out of our time together.

Use of prior and emerging experience:  This was hard to do with our Tibbetts group, because as I mentioned before, they hadn’t studied WWII.  It made it really interesting for our group of leaders though because we had to learn how to connect different scenes that weren’t specific to WWII with things that were happening in their lives.  There is always something they can connect to, even if it is a very small piece of information – but you have to start somewhere!

Reflectiveness:  I’ve noticed a really weird thing.  I thought it was a totally novel and great experience to have kids journal about everything.  Reflect and grow when they are learning…but they are just tired of it!  I’m not sure how or why it has crossed them.  I wonder if it may be that reflecting means a lot of times that we have to deal with hard things about life and ourselves and our society doesn’t value that.  I get caught up in resisting reflection for that very reason.  It’s hard to reflect.  It’s hard to come into direct contact with ourselves.  We need to teach our kids that it is ok for things not to be picture perfect.  That is where the growing happens.  That is where we find ourselves in spite of ourselves.

Enter supporting content here